Would you like to save as your currency permanently or for this visit only?
The Edition has become my favorite hotel in NYC. It's modern and clean without being trendy. It's luxury without being pretentious. The service was first class. The rooms were spacious, clean, and quiet. Even at $500-$600 a night it's a value. The restaurants and bars were fantastic. I think being across from Madison Park adds something unique. I highly recommend the Edition. Didn't love the elevator set up.
Room, Lobby Bar, Hotel Staff Complimentary coffee in lobby bar ends at 8am - too early!
the room and the position and the "edginess" of the hotel our first room (before we changed) only had a shower and not also a bath
Valet took >45 minutes after being told 10-15 (I allowed 20). Had to request iron, wastes time. Tub drain was fully clogged and GROSS so water did not drain. Shower vent grate was FULL of GROSS dust + mold. Noise outside from traffic, garbage trucks + roof party letting out kept us awake ALL NIGHT, absurd! Sounded like windows on Lex.ave. were open, but they weren't, they're just inadequate!
Room set up Very poor service! I had water & juice poured over me during breakfast with no apologies! Tea was served without tea cup! Bathroom light was out for one day and not replaced. Laundry list was not provided despite repeated requests.
Location is great - the art is amazing and the roof top terrace restaurant/ bar is top
The service, room, restaurant, location were excellent.
unique, great location - very little street noise.
The rooms were cute. Not to small. Stayed here for New Year's Eve. Wanted a bucket of ice for the room so my wife and I could keep a bottle of champagne cold. They actually charged us $5 for the bucket of ice. Not even Motel 6 charges for ice. Room was also very hot and a lot of noise from the street and hallway. Bed hard and uncomfortable.
The staff was really friendly and helpful. The hotel design and atmosphere were great. The bed was very uncomfortable - really hard. I stay at alot of boutique / pricey hotels and this was the worst bed I've had.
Very Very cool. From a British viewpoint it is like Malmaison but taken to the next level and with the addition of 5 star service. The concierge are very good at getting you into those 'hard to book' restaurants. The private guests only rooftop bar is very nice.
Staff were very helpful and always on hand. The room quality was very high - the recent refurbishment has really focussed on top end materials and furnishings and for a hotel in central New York, the room was of a good size. Its central location in NYC is very helpful to get uptown or downtown and its situation gives an unusually peaceful night sleep in such a busy city. The roof garden was very nice, as were the bars, but some of the hotel claims are overdone. Cocktails are expensive by the time you add on service and tax.
location is fabulous, rooftop bar was very nice. the room was very small.
Outstanding hotel with excellent staff and tons of character. Rooms are super clean. Great location. Would love to stay here again!
This guest did not leave comments about this hotel.
This guest did not leave comments about this hotel.
My husband and I absolutely loved the Nomad Hotel. The staff, every single one of them were extremely helpful, pleasant and fun. I can't say enough about the service. The room was beautiful and the bed was very comfortable. The library bar was very cool. I could hear water noise from the neighboring room's bathroom. That was a little disturbing in the early morning and late night.
All the staff were amazing. Unique ambiance and furnishings exude class and style. Library Bar is beautiful, always had a spot for me; wonderful service, drinks. Great location, easy to get anywhere. Very memorable!
Beautiful hotel in a great location.
Service and Staff. No
This guest did not leave comments about this hotel.
Very friendly staff. We had a very quiet and gorgeous room. Cool bar. No.
great bar view, we didn't have then best
Staff was attentive. Good location and hotel itself has a nice, trendy bar. N/A
This guest did not leave comments about this hotel.
Having only one person at the desk (much of the time) meant that the level of service was not as high/prompt as it could have been--
All the options, wonderful breakfast and service
Perfect för a family. Breakfast in the morning and wine in the evening.
Central location, you pay the price for the room, everything else is complementary, luxurious room, nice breakfast.
Rooms were clean, staff was attentive, afternoon complimentary wine and cheese was a nice touch. There was nothing negative about our stay.
Staff are really helpful and attentive especially Gabrielle who ensured the Prosecco was topped up regularly! The breakfast and wine and cheese at 5 are a lovely touch and give the hotel a warm, friendly atmosphere. The suites are ideal for families. Location is also ideal for walking or getting subway. Can't rate this hotel highly enough! Nothing.
The staff was very pleasant and helpful. We tried to get an early check in, but it was not available.
Beautiful room and service was great. Breakfast was excellent there was alot of noice outside my room on the 5th floor at 5am
The continental breakfast & the wine & cheese evenings. The fact that the roof terrace was simply that, a roof terrace and not a bar where you could purchase drink or snacks, it seemed a waste of space.
Very nice stay. Just a little too costly.
Easy-going welcome. Free coffee/nibbles in lounge made good and relaxing meeting space.
Lovely atmosphere, friendly staff. Good location.
Nothing Stuff were not friendly
The hotel's location, design and price. That breakfast wasn't include in the price.
The location was excellent, walking distance to 5th. and Empire State, just great.
Very central - good place in Manhattan! The hotel is too expensive for the comfort you get there. the rooms look like a youth-hostel also the sanitary-equipment but the hotel wants a price like a midclass-hotel! not OK!!!
full of character, felt like I was in NY and not just a boring, standard hotel room that could have been anywhere in the world. more hot water please, shower mid day only gave me warm water.
The art was was amazing, such a quirky hotel! location was very central, great value for money!
Good location for Maceys, Empire State Building and sightseeing tour buses.
The room was comfortable but no view. The location was convenient. The counter staff were rather aloof and totally inflexible with regards to the check in check out times.
The name It was too noisy, especially on the 3rd floor...I Could hear very loud garbage trucks from about 3 am until 4:30 am----ugh!
professional hotel staff; artistic interior design throughout the hotel; the location; the Birch cafe with great coffee and food and the common Library room. it would be great if hairdryers are available on demand for guests staying in dorms.
The hotel has a very interesting interior design. It's confortable and welcoming. My only complaint would go to some amount of corridor noise, since the door and wall isolation is not that good.
It was very close to the art and other things we wanted to see.
Location is excellent, pizza restaurant two doors even better! Nothing
I was skeptical about such a good rate but Wyndham is a decent brand so I went for it. Super friendly staff, quick check-in and out. Room was the "cozy" size you'd expect in Manhattan which more than served the purpose. I'll definitely keep this on my list of places to check first next time I'm NY bound.
Good location. Housekeepnng threw away my contact lens solution, they opened the window when they cleaned so my room was freezing every night when I got back. Three days in a row my key didn't work and I had to go back downstairs to have it reprogramed. There was a super funky smell in the room. Thin walls, I could here doors slamming, people talking, etc. There was a thermostat and another heater. When I would turn the thermostat off, the other heater stayed on and I was boiling at night. Internet was really slow. Elevators were also super slow. Poor water pressure in the shower.
The staff was great
The location was convenient for out of towners and the rooms were clean and modern. The shower was excellent. I don't travel to spend excessive time in my hotel room- it's just a comfortable, clean place to sleep and located centrally. This place qualifies. That staff was lovely. There was nothing to complain about. Hotel room coffee is terrible but there's a Starbucks at the end of the block and local coffee houses just a bit further away.
Location and value for money
the beds were very comfortable quiet The deadbolt on the door was broken couldn't get it fixed. Our room keys continually stopped working no information in room about area hallway was filthy had not been vacuumed in a long time they provided a continental breakfast but since we booked through third party website they would not let us eat breakfast.
Friendliness of staff Small rooms, not big enough discount rates for using garage
Everthing is good
Everything! The staff was nice, the location is great, it was right in the centre of it all. Though the view wasn't great (surrounded by other tall buildings), there's so many things to do outside your hotel room, so I'm not sure you should complain about that. The water pressure was a little weak. That's it.
Location was fantastic, very quiet, not a lot of rooms on each floor, and the bathrooms were surprisingly big. Actual room was a bit tight, but that's not a big deal, especially when you consider the location.
Locations was fantastic Free breakfast was difficult, the 4th floor was too cramped I could not even try the food
Perfect location for where I needed to be. Quick check-in and check-out. Comfortable bed/linens/pillow. Nice windows, sunny. Way too noisy. Was on 2nd floor, heard traffic and music from the club next door all night. Had to sleep with headphones on to drown out the noise. No curtains or blackout shades on the windows. With two walls being filled with windows, the blinds did nothing to block out all the street lights and signage outside. I would stay again but only if on a much higher floor and on the back side of building. (or bring a sleep mask)
The position is great. The Empire State Bldg is quite close, as well as Times Square and Union Square. You are in the heart of Manhattan! On top of that, the room was super-super-clean and very comfortable. The hotel had some problem with credit cards, however the staff was very willing to co-operate to solve.
great location. loud neighbors.
Rooms were very spacious
Nothing. I didn't like it. Poor breakfast and the space used as wasn't right for it. The Hotel was very expensive and it isn't look like a three star Hotel.
The room was a decent size and clean. It had everything as described. There was very little traffic noise, which was good as a number of people had complained about that when I read the reviews The breakfast room really needs to be larger as it was a bit crowded.
I liked the location,rooms were quiet and very comfortable. Breakfast area could be improved,a bit small. But selection for breakfast was not bad.
The Hotel was need everywhere we want to go. We could walk to so many places. No
Exactly what I needed. No frills, but clean and the room was a nice size.
Staff were extremely friendly and helpful. Bathroom was well equipped and good sized for this price range hotel. Room was fairly quiet. Breakfast choices were very limited and unhealthy. Elevators were not very functional.
No mini fridge
The staff were excellent. Waiting a whole week to remove the obligatory room charge for incidentals not purchased. Stayed at the Liaison Capitol Hill in DC the following week and was not charged anything against my card at check in.
Much roomier than expected for a Manhattan hotel, very clean and comfortable. A hotel service fee was tacked on at end of stay. This was an annoyance and I had to request staff remove the fee. They tried to tell me it was in the agreement, but I showed them my online receipt. They removed the charge right away, but it felt like this was a purposeful attempt and I'd bet many people don't even argue the charge.
Convenience, two blocks from the Metro. You can walk to Times Square. Bathroom was a bit cramped. No bacon for breakfast:(
Loved the bed and shower - memory foam mattress and a badass shower. Felt similar to a European hotel, smaller yet felt big enough. Great lighting, heating, and staff was great. Not much. Had a great stay!
Location Construction at 3am Overpriced Didn't clean my room until 4pm one day
Easy subway and walking distance to stores. Nice room. Noisy street traffic on Broadway. No decent mirror in room, bathroom had a TV built in, so wasn't useful, full length was in a dark corner.
Location, Room was clean and staff was helpful The price of the hotel was so much cheaper booking through them that i ended up canceling the 2 of the 3 nights and booking.com would not match or give me the price of the hotels rate.
Good Location. Near to good restaurants. A typical 3 star hotel given its room and facilities. Worth the room rates and good for a short 1 or 2 day stay in new york city.
very nice location,situated right in the middle of everything, with easy walks to many sights and easy acces to subway less than 100 meters away. hotel is nice and clean. had 10 th floor room facing backyard with some view and no street noise at all. breakfast is fine...coffee is better than at the Plaza..helpfull staff..would stay again..
Clean, classey, great views and stylish. Breakfasts were included and just what was required. Great location. New luggage set damaged when in storage with the hotel the day after check-out. Made for a miserable return trip as wheel and handle mechanism were well ineffective.
Terrific location just a few blocks away from subway and business traveler necessities like FedEx and a grocery store (Whole Foods to be exact). The room was the most spacious I've stayed in NYC for this price. Near an Orange Theory which I used on my first day there. The gym facilities here are very limited. I did not ask if there were reciprocal gyms nearby.
Good location -the room was comfortable - and the free breakfast was a nice touch if you want to get up and go.
Cleanliness and breakfast as most NY hotels do not have this service location
nice clean bathroom breakfast was of a low standard
comfortable bed, good breakfast
Clean, comfortable room. Helpful staff. Excellent location. I cannot recommend this hotel too highly.
Very friendly staff. Great location
It was very convenient to all the things we wanted to do. Small place with a friendly staff. I was able to park on the street all weekend. I expect to pay ~$300/night, but this wasn't up to the fee. The pillows are undersized by about 1/3. The room layout made it hard to get to the window side of the bed. There was no mini fridge. The nice rainfall shower head had no way for height-challenged people to change its position. The toilet seats are cheap plastic. No electric outlet on one side of the bed, inexcusable in the day of "I charge my phone while I sleep." The lighting scheme, involving use of your room card in a slot and a pad of push button switches, is inscrutable.
The bathroom only had one bar of soap, should have for sink and for shower. They advertise bathrobes but should know if one or two people are staying and have enough robes.
The staff was really helpful, friendly and polite. It is well located. This hotel is very over rated here. They show themeselves as a design hotel in their pictures just because they have a red wall in the reception and some drawings on the staircase walls. The rooms are just white, plain with huge, ugly, brown furniture that takes up all the tiny space. The only light source in single rooms is a very bright white lamp on the roof. Not even a side table lamp. The shower has no door, just a glass panel that covers half the entrance, so every time you shower the whole bathroom floor gets wet, since you can't even regulate the intensity of the water. The place for having "breakfast" is a joke. It's just a tiny space with 4 chairs behind the reception and a table with some breads & coffee. Juice is charged apart.
We had a double/double room and it was had plenty of room and it was very clean and well presented.The staff on reception were very helpful and complimentary breakfast excellent to get you started for the day.Very well located for seeing the city without being very noisy.
The MAve, or the Madison Avenue hotel, is above all "Efficient." And I mean this in the best way. I stayed in the Full size room, and there is NO wasted space, but at the same time it is entirely feasible. The bathrooms are relatively spacious and clean, with new faucets and amenities. The bed was EXCELLENT, and the pillows were great. The front desk employees were VERY friendly and welcoming, even when I arrived quite late in the evening. Check in and out was SIMPLE and easy. Location is SICK beyond compare, particularly for the price. Hot water took 5 minutes to arrive. Breakfast was kind of a joke, but it was free and I can't blame them for trying.
Central location, surrounded by good restaurants, friendly staff always willing to help and give advice
Awesome tv and music channels Nice bathroom. Comfy bed Size of the room itself was tiny.
close to my work place the room is size of king's bed
Our room was a nice size, had an awesomely comfortable King bed. Shower had power. Room got chilly but there was a window unit to fix that. The whole stay I did not hear one peep from any neighboring room. Street sounds of course but that is to be expected. Breakfast is like a circling of the vultures. The table tends to run out of stuff and people wait to pounce. But the quality of the coffee and pastries is worth a small wait.
It was quiet The rooms were SO tiny and I had a bug in my bathroom so wasn't sure how clean it was. Housekeeping did a poor job in my opinion.
Perfect hotel, really clean & confortable. The only weak point is that the windows insonorisation is not good.... you can hear a lot of noice from outside... taxis, alarms ,traffic ...
It was so central to everything-staff were extremely helpful-very comfortable, great bed, bathroom and TV. Easy start to the day having coffee and pastries! We'll be back-thank you again. Nothing
The location and price of this hotel was excellent. Staff was very friendly and remained smiling in the face of adversity. The room was small, but clean with relatively new fixtures. The "free breakfast" is nothing more than coffee and pastry. It was good, but web sites should say "grab and go pastries and coffee." The front desk staff had to wear winter coats and use a space heater because the lobby was so cold. The hotel's internet was not working, so front desk staff had to improvise to process reservations. They did well and with good humor.
Centrally located Loud music from bar next door
Breakfast was good from the bakery down stairs - choice of pastry, a piece of fruit and a coffee and the lady there is lovely! Ask to stay in a room at the back if you can - the street is very noisy at night and the windows are not double glazed!!
Chelsea Inn is literally 50 feet from 5th ave in awesome walking distance to everything. great location. Having said that, our bathroom wasn't in our room, we had a separate key and a shared bathroom_ which was clean, just inconvenient, and after a full 7 hours of walking be prepared to climb some stairs because you might be on the 4th floor and there is no elevator :-)
I can highly recommend a stay at the Chelsea Inn. Lot's of stairs but a great room for a good price. Union square and Broadway is close by and you can easly walk to Little Italy or Chinatown! If you can't walk that many stairs this is not the hotel for you
It was one block from where we needed to go the most often. My husbands favorite coffee place was next door. (Petite abelle). The staff was friendly and helpful. And the room was newly renovated with high ceilings and a very pretty contemporary style. The bed was comfortable. Some rooms in this place have a shared bathroom. I booked one with a private. Still this seems to be a common thing in nyc so be careful when booking. We stayed in room 207 which was newly renovated. The only thing lacking was individual temp control, which we fixed with a space heater. A refrigerator and microwave would have been nice too. The room was very small, not good for more than two people.
I asked for a refund and left 4 hours after I got there. I wouldn't recommend it to my worst enemy
The renovated rooms were very nice, however, they had been recently painted and the fumes were overwhelming, so I was transferred to one of the older, non-renovated rooms. Although the bed and furnishings were new (sheets, pillows and wall mounted TV, the walls (paint and plaster) and carpet were what you would expect in a no-tell motel. Also, most of the rooms "shared" a bathroom. Your bedroom had it's own door and you had to leave your room to go into a bathroom which was used by another room. It worked out fine. Still, it is a great value ($65/night booked in advance) for the location! There's a cute french cafe next to it for breakfast and you're never in the room (very small as most NYC hotel rooms) anyway. It was a 5 story walk-up building - no elevator. After looking at 2 rooms (one without a window! and both freshly painted/smelly) we were transferred to the 5th floor and it was a struggle getting the luggage up the 4 flights of stairs (main floor/1st floor). It will be a very nice hotel once the renovation is completed.
Check in time takes almost two hours
Rooms were recently remodeled, or at least mine was. Nicely done with some exposed brick, wood floor, tasteful art and fixtures, great bed, big screen TV. Shared bathroom was also freshly and tastefully done, and clean.... But SHARED. I think they may have some rooms w private baths for more $. They were working on the hallways during my stay, but I don't see how they can fully update vintage structure with its narrow halls and losing stairway. Street noise.
The hotel is affordable for New York City. It is clean, tidy and attractive. There are no extras, but the price is right.
Nothing front desk closed at 9pm so they basically robbed me. It looked like a homeless shelter, only crackhead and whores stay here
In general it appeared to be a nice place. Got a GREAT deal on Kayak. Upon arrival we were given a different room than one we booked. Room we were given should not be rented to paying guests. It was ONLY guest room in the basement, in between boiler room and laundry room. Likely a converted utility closet. Garbage bags in hallway, staff yelling to each other and playing music in laundry room at 7AM. Can't help but think we were assigned this room as 'punishment' for getting such a good deal (nearly half off website price).